Overtime Pay After Taxes: What You Actually Take Home
Overtime pay often feels like it gets taxed at a punishing rate — a big check that somehow doesn't translate into a proportionally big deposit. Here's what's actually happening, and why overtime isn't taxed at a special higher rate the way people assume. Overtime isn't a separate tax category Unless it's paid as a separate, discrete bonus-style payment, overtime pay included in your regular paycheck is taxed exactly the same way as your regular wages — same federal brackets, same FICA rates, same state tax rules. There's no special "overtime tax rate." Why it feels like it's taxed more The confusion usually comes from how withholding tables work. Most payroll withholding tables assume your current paycheck reflects your typical pay for the year — so a paycheck with a big chunk of overtime looks, to the withholding system, like your annualized income is higher than usual. That triggers a higher withholding percentage for that specific p...